Coming soon to a red carpet near you...
Best Picture
12 Years a Slave
American Hustle
Captain Phillips
Dallas Buyers Club
Gravity
Her
Nebraska
The Wolf of Wall
Street
Between 0 and 2 of:
Inside Llewyn Davis
Saving Mr. Banks
As a refresher, we are still operating under the open-ended
Best Picture nominee system. There will be at least five nominees, but no more
than ten. Only the films that command more than 5% of the vote for Best Picture
will make the cut. This is a system that favors passion over consensus. The
movies that make it here have to be loved, not just liked.
By most accounts, the front-runner of the moment is 12 Years a Slave. According to industry
buzz, this is the movie that does for slavery what Schindler’s List did for the Holocaust. You’d have to be a
heartless bastard not to vote for it. 12
Years a Slave is the most critically acclaimed English language film of the
last several years, and it has seemed like an inevitable Oscar sweeper since
the Toronto film fest in September. Its closest competitor is probably sleek,
glossy big studio crime drama American
Hustle. Hot on the heels of The
Fighter and Silver Linings Playbook,
David O. Russell can do no wrong these days. He seems like a filmmaker who is
bound to direct a Best Picture winner sooner rather than later. This time, he’s
pulled out all the stops with a starry cast full of Oscar winners and nominees
and a ‘70s aesthetic that has drawn comparisons to classic Scorsese. This is
already proving to be Russell’s biggest box office hit yet. Both films are
compelling foils to each other, and this could prove to be a close and
entertaining race for the top prize.
The other seeming possibility for the Best Picture win is Gravity, which is probably second to 12 Years a Slave in terms of critical
acclaim and has become a bona fide international box office smash. This rare
intersection of astronomical critical and commercial success might be
impossible to beat at the Oscars if this weren’t a sci-fi film. As it stands,
this film should play extraordinarily well with the Academy’s technical
branches, and executive types love to award big studio blockbusters that prove
Hollywood is not entirely creatively bankrupt. Among the other big studio
prestige dramas, ripped-from-the-headlines docudrama Captain Phillips is the only one I’d consider a lock for a Best
Picture nomination. It’s a movie that people seem to respect more than love,
but money talks, and the Academy pays attention when adult-oriented dramas
break $100 million at the domestic box office.
We’re bound to see a few smaller critical darlings in the
mix. The strongest of these is Nebraska,
Alexander Payne’s homage to Americana for people who have never lived outside
Los Angeles. Oscar pundits were quick to
write this one off after it was coolly received at Cannes, but I knew the American
critics would come to bat for it. Alexander Payne is the master of Baby Boomer
angst, and it seems like he’s hit a nerve with the Academy’s key demographic
yet again. I also think there’s a spot for Her.
Spike Jonze’s futuristic love story will likely not play well to the geriatric
core of the Academy – I don’t know how voters who couldn’t stomach gay cowboys
in Brokeback Mountain will respond to
a man falling in love with his operating system. However, Her will likely be a beneficiary of the Academy’s push to invite
young, hip new members to bring the Oscars into the 21st century.
This is a film that falls firmly into the Tree
of Life/Beasts of the Southern Wild camp of artsy passion picks that get
nominations thanks to the new Best Picture rules.
Lest things get too artsy, we need to consider what else is
going to play well to the middlebrow bread-and-butter of the Academy. Dallas Buyers Club, the least-gay film
ever made about the AIDS epidemic, will likely fit the bill. The Matthew McConaughey-headlined
tearjerker opened to surprisingly good reviews and a solid box office gross for
its budget. The film has had a strong showing with the industry guild awards,
and its scenery chewing histrionics should endear it to the Academy’s sizable
actors branch. This is exactly the kind of whitewashed, Crash-esque message movie that will always find support in the
Academy.
Things get dicey from here. The Wolf of Wall Street is a slam-dunk Best Picture nominee on
paper: it’s a big-budget December studio release directed by Martin Scorsese
and starring Leonardo DiCaprio. However, after watching Leo DiCaprio snort
cocaine out of a hooker’s naughty bits, one has to wonder, “Is this really an
Oscar movie?” Scorsese’s wild chronicle of 1980s Wall Street excess is proving to be divisive among critics
and audiences. An Academy member allegedly screamed, “You should be ashamed of
yourself!” to Scorsese himself at a recent screening. Still, the movie has
passionate fans, and there are Scorsese acolytes in the Academy who will vote
for anything he puts out.
While the expanded Best Picture field has recently allowed nominations
for art-house fare like The Tree of Life
and Amour, it also gave us
nominations for The Blind Side and Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close.
There will always be an audience for sentimental claptrap in the Academy. This
year, that contingent of voters will likely rally behind Saving Mr. Banks. Critics were mixed on the film, and it has an
army of naysayers who are calling it Disney propaganda. However, it is
impossible to deny that the movie is a crowdpleaser. Executive types in the
Academy are no doubt thrilled by the chronicle of a studio mogul putting a stubborn
artist in her place and producing a mega-hit. Other voters are probably happy
to have an Oscar movie they can watch with the whole family in a year full of
racy contenders like American Hustle
and The Wolf of Wall Street. Ultimately,
I think if this film may be too saccharine by even Academy standards. Saving Mr. Banks has a crowded field to contend
with, but don’t be surprised to see it crack the Best Picture lineup.
The other strong contender is another critical darling
passion pick: Inside Llewyn Davis.
This film has extra Oscar prestige thanks to the venerated Coen brothers at the
helm. After No Country for Old Men,
the Coens can suddenly do no wrong by the Academy. Even little-loved A Serious Man pulled off a Best Picture
nomination. Buzz for Inside Llewyn Davis
is oddly quiet for a film that has received superlative reviews since Cannes.
It did well with the critics’ awards and the Golden Globes, but the industry
guild awards have ignored it. It lacks the A-list cast and weighty subject
matter of other Best Picture contenders, but I imagine there are enough Coen
die-hards in the Academy to push this to a nomination. However, it may end up
being a bit too small for the top category.
It’s time for some truth telling. This was not a good year
for Harvey Weinstein. After his back-to-back Best Picture wins for The King’s Speech and The Artist, he by all accounts owned the
Academy. He has a full slate of Academy-friendly fare as usual, but none of it
has made much of an impact this awards season. Still, I would not be shocked if
he placed something in this expanded Best Picture field. The likeliest bet is
the sweeping, star-studded civil rights epic The Butler, which played to $100 million business over the summer.
Reviews were mixed, but this was never going to be a critics’ film. The Butler provides a safer, more
uplifting socially conscious alternative to the brutality of 12 Years a Slave. At the same time, it
might even be too sentimental and calculated for its own good, as even fairly
middle-brow groups like the Producers Guild have given it the cold shoulder.
Harvey also has Fruitvale
Station for Academy voters who prefer more substance to their socially
conscious fare. The Sundance breakout hit seemed destined to join the ranks of Precious and Winter’s Bone, especially after the George Zimmerman trial gave the
film cultural relevance money can’t buy. Despite unanimous critical acclaim,
it’s been oddly absent from the end-of-year awards hoopla. August: Osage County should be Harvey’s easiest Best Picture
nominee in theory – it’s an adaptation of a Pulitzer-winning play starring
Meryl Streep, Julia Roberts, and a slew of other respected thespians trying to
out-Oscar bait each other. The problem is that nobody likes it very much, but
maybe the Meryl Streep stans in the Academy will come through for it. His other
Oscar pony, Judi Dench vehicle Philomena,
is a crowd-pleaser and a BAFTA and Golden Globe nominee for Best Picture.
But is that a movie that people are really going to mark down as their #1 of
the year? This year may just be a wash for the Oscar Svengali, but I wouldn’t
count any of these out as potential Best Picture nominees.
There are still a few fringe contenders to highlight. Ron
Howard’s Formula One drama Rush is
precisely the type of well-crafted, easily digestible big studio fare that
tends to score with the Academy. It did well with the Golden Globes and made
money overseas, but it still has “flop” stigma attached to it thanks to its
disappointing domestic box office performance. It will likely get a handful of
nominations, but Best Picture may be a reach. Blue Jasmine probably shouldn’t be counted out. A critically
acclaimed, commercially successful Woody Allen film with the Best Actress
frontrunner in the title role makes perfect sense as a Best Picture nominee. My
problem again is still: where are the #1 votes going to come from? People like
it, but is this anyone’s favorite film of 2013?
Best Director
Alfonso Cuaron, Gravity
Spike Jonze, Her
Steve McQueen, 12
Years a Slave
David O. Russell, American
Hustle
Martin Scorsese, The
Wolf of Wall Street
Alt: Paul Greengrass, Captain Phillips
Last year reminded us that the directors branch is a bit
insular and idiosyncratic. Not even the director of the Best Picture
frontrunner is safe. This year, that would be Steve McQueen for 12 Years a Slave. McQueen is primarily
known as a visual artist, and his first two feature films – Hunger and Shame – were adored in film snob circles but decidedly not up the
Academy’s alley. In his first season playing the awards game, McQueen has
turned some heads with his ornery, dismissive attitude. This might actually be
an asset a year after Ben Affleck likely turned his fellow directors off by
trying too hard. Regardless of his personality, McQueen’s work seems
undeniable. If he wins the Oscar, he will be the first black filmmaker man to
win Best Director.
His likeliest competitor is Alfonso Cuaron for Gravity. After Children of Men, he seemed destined to break into the pantheon of
the greats. With that kind of pressure, it’s no wonder it took him seven years
to release his follow-up. In the end, Gravity
proved to be worth the wait and the exorbitant price tag. Last year, we saw
the most technically demanding and visually involving film take home the Best
Director statuette. Gravity is that
film this year. I can also see David O. Russell winning if American Hustle becomes the Best Picture frontrunner. He’s the
consummate actor’s director these days, and American
Hustle has more stylistic flair than his recent films.
The race looks more uncertain after that. It’s tough to imagine
Martin Scorsese missing out. The Wolf of
Wall Street has more vehement detractors than any other movie in the Oscar
race, but you can usually count on the directors branch to come through for
Scorsese. Even the uber-controversial The
Last Temptation of Christ got Marty a nomination from his peers when every
other branch of the Academy ignored it. He is basically revered as a god among
his fellow directors. He got no love from the critics’ groups and the Golden
Globes, but his nominations from the Directors Guild and BAFTA are likely
telling. It’s been a long time since the directors branch snubbed Marty when he
was a legitimate contender. I'm going out on a limb for the last spot and giving it to Spike Jonze. Her is exactly the kind of visually compelling auteurist piece that
typically plays well with the directors branch. Spike Jonze is already a highly
respected Oscar nominee who other directors love so much that they cast him in
their movies (see: his bit part in The
Wolf of Wall Street). His lack of attention from other mainstream awards
groups gives me pause, but then again the directors branch of the Academy has
always been the likeliest group to recognize him.
There are a few strong spoilers here. Paul Greengrass seems
like a safe bet on paper for Captain Phillips.
He’s a respected previous nominee with a huge box office hit. Any director will
tell you that shooting an entire movie on water is kind of insane, so he will
likely get degree-of-difficulty points. Greengrass has been nominated by just
about every group that matters, but how much passion is there for the film
itself? If Captain Phillips
underperforms on Oscar morning, this will likely be the first category it
misses. Alexander Payne
would make sense as a nominee for Nebraska.
His last two films scored with the directors branch, and he’s gotten attention
for taking stylistic risks in his latest effort. Despite his Golden Globe
nomination, Nebraska feels much
smaller in scope and cultural impact than Sideways
or The Descendants. It doesn’t help
that those two films were big hits while Nebraska
is struggling to hit the $10 million mark in limited release hell. Still, he
has fans who could push him into the final five.
It’s tough to imagine anyone else getting nominated, though
this year is full of Best Picture contenders from Oscar nominees and winners.
If there is a complete out-of-left-field nominee, it will likely be for Oscar
darlings the Coen brothers for Inside
Llewyn Davis or Woody Allen for Blue
Jasmine. Harvey Weinstein tried to turn 24 year-old USC film school grad
Ryan Coogler into this year’s rookie contender for Fruitvale Station (in the mold of last year’s head-scratching nod
for Beasts of the Southern Wild’s
Benh Zeitlin), but I just don’t think anyone cares about that film.
Best Actor
Bruce Dern, Nebraska
Leonardo DiCaprio, The
Wolf of Wall Street
Chiwetel Ejiofor, 12
Years a Slave
Tom Hanks, Captain
Phillips
Matthew McConaughey, Dallas
Buyers Club
Alt: Christian Bale, American
Hustle
This is perhaps the most hotly-contested of any of the
above-the-line races because, surprise surprise, there were a lot of great
roles for men in movies this year.
Leading the pack is Chiwetel Ejiofor for 12 Years a Slave. Ejiofor is one of those actors who have been in
the industry forever but rarely get any recognition (imagine my shock when I
realized he was in Love, Actually during
this year’s annual Christmas viewing). He hit the jackpot with his big Oscar
bait breakout performance. His character is almost impossibly sympathetic, and
every scene is an Oscar clip. He is very much in it to win it, especially if 12 Years a Slave takes the top prize.
The race to the top won’t be easy for Ejiofor. Matthew McConaughey
completed his transformation from rom com star to Serious Actor when he lost 40
pounds to play a dying AIDS patient in Dallas
Buyers Club. The stunt alone would put him on the awards season radar, but
he sealed the deal by proving once and for all that he could actually act.
Couple that with his acclaimed supporting turns this year in Mud and The Wolf of Wall Street and we have the ingredients for a strong
Oscar contender. One also has to seriously pay attention when a star pushes
his/her film to a Best Picture nomination that probably wouldn’t have made it
without them (see also: Ray, The Blind
Side). The other contender for the win is Bruce Dern for Nebraska. It’s been 40 years since Dern
was up for an Oscar, and he is not letting anyone forget it. No actor has
worked the campaign circuit harder this year. The performance isn’t all that
showy, but his presence in the awards race is a nostalgic reminder of the “good
old days” for the older set in the Academy. He’s already taken home a few big
critics’ prizes, and it’s not difficult to imagine his winning streak continuing
through SAG and the Oscars.
Though he won’t win, it is difficult to imagine Tom Hanks
missing a nomination for Captain Phillips.
The film marked his triumphant return to Oscar bait and earned him some of the
best reviews of his career. Hanks is still one of the most popular and beloved
people in Hollywood, and the Academy will be happy to welcome him back. The
last spot is a bit of a crapshoot. I am giving it to Leonardo DiCaprio, whose
film is all anyone can talk about these days. Poor Leo has had pretty lousy
luck with the Academy lately. J. Edgar
and Django Unchained were supposed to
win him that elusive Oscar, but he didn’t even get nominated. This time, he is
back with Martin Scorsese and earned career-best raves from every critic who
matters. Even the film’s most vocal haters admit that his work is staggering.
SAG snubbed him, but he got in with the Golden Globes and BAFTA. Leo has always
been seen in the industry as a bit overeager for recognition, but he has gone
into overdrive this year. Along with appearing on every talk show on the air,
he allegedly wrote letters to every member of the Hollywood Foreign Press
Association making the case for his Golden Globe-worthiness. His history makes me wary, but I think there
will be enough passion for his performance to push him in.
Leo’s biggest problem is another A-lister starring in a
commercially successful Best Picture contender. Christian Bale can’t seem to be
bothered to campaign this year, but his name keeps showing up in discussions
about the Oscar race. Like Leo, Bale is a SAG snubee with recognition from the
Globes and BAFTA. Unlike Leo, he’s not even getting best-in-show reviews, much
less career-best notices. At the same time, American
Hustle is much more beloved in the industry than The Wolf of Wall Street is. David O. Russell’s last film managed an
acting nomination in every category, and I can see the actors branch going all
in for his ensemble again. If Bale gets in, then American Hustle is probably our Best Picture winner.
Then there is the curious case of Robert Redford in All Is Lost. When the film premiered at
Cannes, Oscar pundits declared the Best Actor race over. No one could beat a
living legend like Redford giving a spellbinding silent performance that took
up every second of his film. His win from the New York Film Critics’ Circle
seemed to be the start of his steamroll through awards season. Then he was
ignored by SAG and BAFTA. It begs a serious question: is anyone watching this
movie? The paltry box office gross would suggest: no. Still, he poses a strong
chance to upset. He is a potential passion pick who benefits from the Academy’s
preferential balloting system. I mean, who doesn’t love Robert Redford?
Harvey Weinstein’s best chance here is Forest Whitaker for The Butler. He got a SAG nomination, but
he doesn’t have a ton of buzz for someone who is really working the circuit.
Ultimately, the performance is too quiet to stand out in a field of flashy
contenders, especially since his movie is likely not getting a Best Picture
nomination. Joaquin Phoenix is headlining a likely Best Picture nominee in Her. After Harvey dragged him kicking
and screaming through last year’s awards circuit, he’s stayed completely out of
the dog and pony show this time. I don’t think he’s much of a contender despite
his great reviews. On the extreme outskirts, we have buzzy breakout
performances like Oscar Isaac in Inside
Llewyn Davis and Michael B. Jordan in Fruitvale
Station who would likely fare better in a less crowded year.
Best Actress
Amy Adams, American
Hustle
Cate Blanchett, Blue
Jasmine
Sandra Bullock, Gravity
Judi Dench, Philomena
Emma Thompson, Saving
Mr. Banks
Alt: Meryl Streep, August:
Osage County
Nailing down this category is like pulling teeth. All six
top contenders make sense, but someone has to miss. Cate Blanchett is probably
our winner here after nearly sweeping every critics’ award for Blue Jasmine. Even this self-proclaimed
Blanchett hater admits that she is stellar in that film, and Hollywood is eager
to welcome her back after her extended hiatus to focus on theater. We’ve all
known that her second Oscar win was inevitable, so let’s go ahead and get it
over with.
Sandra Bullock got career-best raves for Gravity and proved once more that she is
one of the few reliable box office draws left in Hollywood. She’s in, and she
would be a contender for the win had she not just won for The Blind Side. I don’t foresee two-time Academy Award winner
Sandra Bullock happening. Judi Dench, like the grandest of British dames always
do, received glowing reviews for playing herself in Philomena and will likely be rewarded with yet another pointless
Oscar nomination. Harvey Weinstein has done an excellent job of reminding us
that she’s going blind and may never make a film again. She is one of Harvey’s
few surefire chances at a nomination this year (and she allegedly had his name
tattooed on her butt), and he will not mess it up.
Emma Thompson basically ruled the Academy Awards in the
1990s, becoming the only woman to win Oscars for acting and writing. It’s been
nearly 20 years she was seriously in contention, but she’s back with a
vengeance this year as P.L. Travers in Saving
Mr. Banks. She has good reviews for the film (it’s a performance she could
do in her sleep), but more importantly she is campaigning like a madwoman and
reminding everyone why they’ve always loved her. Much like in Tom Hanks’ case,
the Academy is likely happy to welcome Emma Thompson back. I’m giving the last
spot to Amy Adams for American Hustle.
After four nominations in the Supporting Actress category, Amy is trying her
luck in the leading category. It’s been a bumpy ride thus far, as most critics
contend that Jennifer Lawrence stole the film with half the screentime. Still,
Adams has drawn her own fair share of acclaim, and her surprise BAFTA
nomination is likely a sign of things to come. As always, she is doing the work
on the campaign trail, and she is well-liked in the industry. I think she’ll be
swept in with the general love for American
Hustle.
It feels slightly silly to talk about Amy Adams being
well-liked in the industry when I have Meryl Streep sitting on the outside
looking in. She is, by all accounts, a goddess among men in the eyes of the
acting community. August: Osage County
should be an easy nomination for her. Violet Weston is one of the plumb
Broadway roles of the last decade, and any actress of a certain age would kill
to play it on stage or screen. When Meryl landed the part in the film version,
she was declared the sight-unseen Oscar winner of whatever year it came out. I
suppose no one guessed the film would be a turkey. Critics usually still laud
Meryl when her movies are bad (The Iron
Lady), but even she got some high-profile pans this time around. Still, this is the kind of in-your-face,
scenery-devouring ACTING that will always have its partisans in the Academy.
She received recognition from the Golden Globes and SAG, but BAFTA shunned her
in a rather bold move. After 30+ years of being a perennial nominee, is the
Meryl Streep Golden Age over? Now that she finally has her third Oscar, the
Academy may decide to take a break. Even Academy favorites like Susan Sarandon
and Shirley MacLaine stopped getting nominated after winning an overdue Oscar.
Still, it’s Meryl Streep and Harvey Weinstein. I’m not going to be surprised if
she still gets in at the expense of Amy Adams (or Emma Thompson?!).
The somewhat surprising nomination for Emmanuelle Riva last
year has some pundits searching for another foreign contender. There is some
heat behind Adele Exarchopoulos for Blue
is the Warmest Color, but probably not enough. I just can’t imagine the
average Academy member sitting through a three-hour French erotic lesbian
drama, no matter how critically acclaimed it is. Exarchopoulos tied Cate
Blanchett for the prestigious Los Angeles Film Critics Association prize, but
she hasn’t been much of a factor elsewhere. It’s worth noting that Kate Winslet
got a Golden Globe nomination for Jason Reitman’s Labor Day. Reitman’s name used to carry prestige clout, but I don’t
think anyone takes him seriously anymore. Winslet is another case where the
Academy is probably done nominating her now that she has her “overdue” Oscar.
This year boasted a slew of superb female performances in independent cinema
(shout out to Brie Larson in Short Term
12 and Greta Gerwig in Frances Ha),
but sadly none of them are on the Academy’s radar.
Best Supporting Actor
Barkhad Abdi, Captain
Phillips
Bradley Cooper, American
Hustle
Michael Fassbender, 12
Years a Slave
Jonah Hill, The Wolf of Wall Street
Jonah Hill, The Wolf of Wall Street
Jared Leto, Dallas
Buyers Club
Alt: Daniel Bruhl, Rush
I can’t believe I am typing this sentence, but Jared Leto is
winning an Oscar and nothing can stop him. His performance as a transgendered
woman with a heart of gold in Dallas
Buyers Club is certainly transformative and showy, and it also fulfills one
of Oscar’s favorite archetypes: the magical minority who helps our hero along
his journey (think Morgan Freeman in Million
Dollar Baby and Whoopi Goldberg in Ghost).
He’s already cleaned up with the critics’ awards, and will likely continue to
do so until the Oscars. Michael Fassbender is in a distant second place for his
portrayal of the sadistic plantation master in 12 Years a Slave. He has plenty of scenery to chew on, and the
Academy loves nominating villains in the Supporting Actor category. It looks
like Steve McQueen’s muse will finally have his day at the Oscars after his
rather cruel snub for Shame two years
ago.
I feel oddly confident that Barkhad Abdi is getting in for Captain Phillips. His performance was
showy enough, and the script did him many favors by humanizing what could have
been a very one-dimensional character. Sony has done an excellent job of
putting him out on the campaign circuit to prove that he is not actually a
Somali pirate. He got in with every televised awards group, and I expect the
Academy to follow suit. Bradley Cooper is also a good bet for American Hustle. Broad comic relief is
always popular in the supporting categories, and Cooper is still riding high on
the love he got last year for Silver
Linings Playbook. The love for American
Hustle is strong in the actors branch, and Cooper will be a beneficiary.
The last slot is tricky, but I’m going out on a limb and giving it to Jonah Hill for The Wolf of Wall Street. The movie is peaking at the right time, and Hill is central to some of the film's most epic set pieces (the quaaludes scene alone is nomination-worthy). He's had buzz all season long, but the televised awards shut him out. Still, we usually get a WTF nomination in the supporting categories (Michael Shannon in Revolutionary Road, Max Von Sydow in Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, etc.), and I am throwing caution to the wind and attempting to get ahead of the curve on this one. Hill is an Oscar nominee in a field of Hollywood outsiders, and I get the impression that people in the industry really like him. It could be enough to eke out a nomination.
The smart money is on Daniel Bruhl for Rush. On paper it makes sense, as he got that golden SAG+Globe+BAFTA combo in the run up to the Oscar nominations. He’s the co-lead of his film, and it was quite the flashy, scenery-chewing performance. He’s also playing a real person, which should give him some extra Oscar mojo. But does anyone care about Rush? That just does not strike me as a high-priority awards season viewing film for most Oscar voters. I think he will be this year's surprising snub-ee who hit all the right precursors but failed to generate the passion for an Oscar nomination.
The smart money is on Daniel Bruhl for Rush. On paper it makes sense, as he got that golden SAG+Globe+BAFTA combo in the run up to the Oscar nominations. He’s the co-lead of his film, and it was quite the flashy, scenery-chewing performance. He’s also playing a real person, which should give him some extra Oscar mojo. But does anyone care about Rush? That just does not strike me as a high-priority awards season viewing film for most Oscar voters. I think he will be this year's surprising snub-ee who hit all the right precursors but failed to generate the passion for an Oscar nomination.
James Gandolfini is a possible spoiler for Enough Said. Obviously the guy is still
riding the sympathy wave following his unexpected death last summer. The movie
was a minor hit, and his reviews were strong. He got a SAG nomination, but I
think the buck stops there. Let’s face it: James Gandolfini was a television
actor. He was respected, but these are not the Emmys. If no one cares about Rush, I am 100% no one in the actors
branch gives two craps about Enough Said.
Posthumous nominations usually only happen if the performance would have made
the cut anyway (think Heath Ledger in The
Dark Knight). That is definitely not the case here. It’s a subtle,
understated performance in a well-received, but ultimately not Oscar-baity
film.
An upset could come from a number of Best Picture
contenders. Maybe the actors branch will go really wild for American Hustle and Jeremy Renner can
get in here alongside Bradley Cooper. Will Forte got a few critics’ award
mentions for Nebraska, but I can’t
imagine anyone actually voting for him. Tom Hanks is also a possible spoiler
for his work as Walt Disney in Saving Mr.
Banks.
Best Supporting
Actress
Jennifer Lawrence, American
Hustle
Lupita Nyong’o, 12
Years a Slave
Julia Roberts, August:
Osage County
June Squibb, Nebraska
Oprah Winfrey, Lee
Daniels’ The Butler
Alt: Sally Hawkins, Blue
Jasmine
Jennifer Lawrence is the Queen of Hollywood and is very
likely walking away with her second Oscar in two years. At age 23, she will
become the youngest person to receive three Oscar nominations (the late Teresa
Wright did it at 24). Should she win,
she will be the youngest person to win two Oscars (Luise Rainer was 27 when she
set the record 76 years ago). She has best-in-show raves in a Best Picture
frontrunner, and she already has the Golden Globe and wins from the New York
Film Critics’ Circle and the National Society of Film Critics. Even though she
just won, I think she will become undeniable.
If anyone can stop the JLaw train, it is Lupita Nyong’o in 12 Years a Slave. The recent Yale Drama
grad has received “star is born” raves for her debut film performance. She has quickly
become a red carpet fixture, and she has won many in the industry over with her
charm and humility. I also think Oprah is a surefire nominee despite her snub
from the Golden Globes. While she got some outright pans, most agree that she
acquitted herself nicely in The Butler.
For the most well-connected person in Hollywood, that should be enough. Oprah
has been pounding the pavement for this nomination, and frankly I would be
afraid to not vote for her if I were in the actors branch. And really, who doesn’t want to see Oprah at
the Oscars?
After that, I expect to see June Squibb recognized for her
work as a foul-mouthed granny in Nebraska.
Squibb is a complete no-name, but the actors branch likes to recognize
long-toiling character actors who finally break through. And as I said before,
there is always room for broad comic relief in the supporting categories. I’m
giving the last spot to Julia Roberts for August:
Osage County. The movie is a flop, but I think voters will be happy to have
Julia back on the awards circuit for the first time since she won 13 years ago.
It feels weird to predict her and not Meryl Streep, but the supporting actress
category is simply less competitive.
If anyone can upset this group, it’s Sally Hawkins for Blue Jasmine. Hawkins is another one of
those nose-to-the-grind character actors who struggle for recognition, but she
certainly has a higher profile than June Squibb. She pulled off nominations
from the Globes and BAFTA, and it’s not hard to see the Academy following suit.
It’s not uncommon for strong lead acting contenders to pull along their
supporting co-stars for a surprise nomination (see: Maggie Gyllenhaal in Crazy Heart).
Scarlett Johansson has buzz for her work as the seductive
operating system in Her, but I can’t
imagine the Academy going for a voice performance. Octavia Spencer has been
working the campaign circuit for her performance in Fruitvale Station. The grieving mother is a popular Oscar
archetype, but the film just doesn’t seem to be registering in the industry.
There are some murmurings around the web about Jennifer Garner sneaking in for Dallas Buyers Club. She literally has
nothing to work with in that film, but after Jacki Weaver’s nomination for Silver Linings Playbook last year, I
have to concede that anything is possible if the Academy likes the movie
enough. That could similarly be good news for Margot Robbie if The Wolf of Wall Street has enough fans
in the actors branch.
Best Original
Screenplay
American Hustle
Blue Jasmine
Her
Inside Llewyn Davis
Nebraska
Alt: Enough Said
The screenwriting categories this year seem eerily obvious,
which is never a good thing. The writers branch likes to throw curveballs more
than almost anyone else in the Academy. Still, the frontrunners for Original
Screenplay are pure writers branch catnip. I mean…… David O. Russell, Spike
Jonze, Woody Allen, the Coen brothers. It would be foolish to leave any of them
off the list. Alexander Payne didn’t even write Nebraska, but I’d be surprised if a good chunk of the Academy
realized that. That film is his voice through and through.
If anything is vulnerable from that list, it’s Inside Llewyn Davis, which was snubbed
by the Writers Guild. Still, one has to remember that the Academy writers
branch is more highbrow than their WGA brethren (which includes people who
write, like….commercials). At WGA, the Coen brothers missed to Dallas Buyers Club, which is just not
going to happen at the Oscars. No matter how beloved that film is throughout
the rest of the Academy, it is just not a writers branch kind of film.
If the writers branch veers from the obvious five, it will
likely be for indie hit Enough Said.
Nicole Holofcener is probably the most respected female writer/director in the
biz these days, and it seems right that she will get her first Oscar nomination
soon. The movie has some Oscar buzz thanks to James Gandolfini, but the writers
branch is likelier to go for it than the actors branch.
Then there is the case of Gravity, which is by all accounts a major Best Picture contender.
Still, the film has been criticized for its screenplay, and the writers branch
has been known to ignore more visually-driven Best Picture contenders these
days (Avatar, Black Swan). If it
somehow gets this nomination, look out for it as a serious contender for the
Best Picture win.
Fruitvale Station fits
the bill as the annual Sundance contender, but the buzz just isn’t there
anymore. Saving Mr. Banks was
considered the best unproduced screenplay in Hollywood for a while, but
naturally everyone says the script is lousy now that the movie is out. It may
be a tearjerker, but the writers are the least-likely voters to appreciate that
film.
Best Adapted
Screenplay
12 Years a Slave
Before Midnight
Captain Phillips
Philomena
The Wolf of Wall
Street
Alt: August: Osage County
Unlike the Original Screenplay race, this category is pretty
light on Best Picture contenders. 12
Years a Slave probably has this Oscar sewn up. After that, the likeliest
nominee is Before Midnight, which is
one of this year’s critical darlings and has Sundance cred to boot. The writers
nominated Before Sunset nine years
ago, and they should follow that trend here.
The other two Best Picture contenders here, Captain Phillips and The Wolf of Wall Street, might have been
snubbed by the writers in a weaker year, but I honestly can’t think of stronger
substitutes. Ditto Philomena, which
has been praised for its writing even if the film is very slight. August: Osage County made it in with the
Writers Guild. It has Pulitzer winner Tracy Letts’ name on it, and I don’t
think people generally blame him for the film’s shortcomings. Still, it will be
hard for the script to overcome the general lack of love for the film.
What else is there? If the writers want to go arty and
foreign, Blue is the Warmest Color
may appeal to them. However, that is more of an acting/directing kind of film. The Spectacular Now could have some supporters
who want to fill this category with more indie fare. Lone Survivor pulled off a surprise Writers Guild nomination, but
again, the snobby Academy writers branch is not likely to embrace that one.
And now the rest……
Best Foreign Language
Film
The Broken Circle
Breakdown (Belgium)
The Grandmaster (Hong
Kong)
The Great Beauty (Italy)
The Hunt (Denmark)
Omar (Palestine)
Alt: The Missing Picture (Cambodia)
Best Animated Film
Despicable Me 2
Ernest and Celestine
Frozen
Monsters University
The Wind Rises
Alt: The Croods
Best Documentary
Feature
20 Feet from Stardom
The Act of Killing
Blackfish
The Square
Stories We Tell
Alt: Tim’s Vermeer
Best Film Editing
12 Years a Slave
American Hustle
Captain Phillips
Gravity
The Wolf of Wall
Street
Alt: Rush
Best Cinematography
12 Years a Slave
The Grandmaster
Gravity
Inside Llweyn Davis
Prisoners
Alt: Nebraska
Best Production
Design
12 Years a Slave
Gravity
The Great Gatsby
The Hobbit: The
Desolation of Smaug
Saving Mr. Banks
Alt: Inside Llewyn
Davis
Best Costume Design
12 Years a Slave
American Hustle
The Great Gatsby
The Invisible Woman
Saving Mr. Banks
Alt: Oz the Great and
Powerful
Best Makeup and
Hairstyling
American Hustle
Dallas Buyers Club
The Lone Ranger
Alt: Band Grandpa
Best Original Score
12 Years a Slave
The Book Thief
Gravity
Monsters University
Saving Mr. Banks
Alt: Philomena
Best Original Song
Frozen – “Let It
Go”
The Great Gatsby –
“Young and Beautiful”
Her – “The Moon
Song”
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom - "Ordinary Love"
One Chance – “Sweeter Than Fiction”
One Chance – “Sweeter Than Fiction”
Alt: Lee Daniels’ The
Butler – “You and I Ain’t Nothin’ No More”
Best Sound Mixing
12 Years a Slave
Captain Phillips
Inside Llewyn Davis
Gravity
Lone Survivor
Alt: Rush
Best Sound Editing
All is Lost
Captain Phillips
Frozen
Frozen
Gravity
Lone Survivor
Alt: Rush
Best Visual Effects
Gravity
The Hobbit: The
Desolation of Smaug
Iron Man 3
Pacific Rim
Star Trek: Into
Darkness
Alt: Oblivion